Monday, May 29, 2006

Your regulators will protect you: Yet another botch from Queensland Health

A cosmetic surgeon who quit Victoria after botching seven operations has been disciplined in Queensland over another surgery bungle. Gold Coast-based Graydon Ronald Van Houten was found guilty of unsatisfactory professional conduct over an operation to remove a cyst from the ear of Browns Plains retiree Bob Martin in August 2001. The wound failed to heal and specialists had to remove part of Mr Martin's ear after a routine check-up three months later showed the cyst was a carcinoma.

The incident has raised concerns about how Dr Van Houten was allowed to practise in Queensland despite the adverse findings against him in Victoria. Mr Martin, 64, reached an out-of-court settlement with Dr Van Houten which prevented him from naming the surgeon. But searches of public documents, which name Dr Van Houten, reveal The Medical Board of Queensland in January ruled the 60-year-old not be allowed to perform various skin procedures until he completed courses on skin cancer practice.

Mr Martin said the ordeal had devastated him. "When I walk into shopping centres now people point at me say, 'Look at that man, he has only half an ear.' People are always saying, 'What happened to you?' " Mr Martin said. He said the compensation amounted to "chicken feed" after his legal and hospital bills were paid.

In its findings, the panel noted the Medical Practitioners Board of Victoria in October 2002 had found Dr Van Houten had engaged in unprofessional conduct of a serious nature in the treatment of four patients and unprofessional conduct not of a serious nature in the treatment of three other patients. He escaped suspension because he had moved to Queensland and his Victorian registration had lapsed.

Mr Martin's lawyer Bruce Simmonds said the Queensland panel, despite being aware of the Victorian cases, had imposed little punishment on the doctor apart from requiring him to undergo some training. "I understand he is offering the same types of services here which led to the complaints in Victoria," Mr Simmonds said.

Marilyn Van Houten, a practice manager at her husband's surgery, defended him. "He has no problems that he isn't working through. He's addressed the issues at hand," she said. "Why aren't the newspapers supporting doctors . . . we're not talking about Dr Patel here." The Medical Board of Queensland said recent changes in legislation had led to improved checks on interstate doctors and a public register being established where patients could check doctors' records.

Source






Federal Health Minister Abbott blasts Queensland hospital ban on Bible

Queensland Health are much better at political correctness than they are at medical correctness

Federal Health Minister Tony Abbott has accused Queensland hospital bosses of "losing the plot" after they banned the Bible from bedsides. An outraged Mr Abbott launched his scathing attack, following a Sunday Mail report which revealed the religious books had been removed amid fears of offending non-Christians. Mr Abbott said the Federal Government was giving $9 billion to Queensland to run public hospitals efficiently - not to ban the Bible.

The Royal Brisbane and Princess Alexandra hospitals are among those in the firing line. Staff said the Bibles had been removed because they were no longer in keeping with the "multicultural approach to chaplaincy", while some claimed the books were a source of infection. Mr Abbott told Federal Parliament: "This is not an infection control measure, it is a thought control measure - it is political correctness gone crazy. "I say to public hospital administrators: Stop worrying about offending people and start running public hospitals properly, and give people Bibles at a time when they probably most want to see them."

Gideons International, which distributes the Bibles, has offered to supply hospitals with hardcover copies which could be wiped to reduce infection fears, but health bosses have rejected the offer. This week they denied that Bibles had been banned from bedsides. "Bibles are available in all hospitals, either at the bedside or on request," Queensland Health Director-General Uschi Schreiber said.

More here

***************************

For greatest efficiency, lowest cost and maximum choice, ALL hospitals and health insurance schemes should be privately owned and run -- with government-paid vouchers for the very poor and minimal regulation. Both Australia and Sweden have large private sector health systems with government reimbursement for privately-provided services so can a purely private system with some level of government reimbursement or insurance for the poor be so hard to do?

Comments? Email me here. If there are no recent posts here, the mirror site may be more up to date. My Home Page is here or here.

***************************

No comments: