Friday, July 15, 2005

YOUR REGULATORS WILL PROTECT YOU

Mentally ill doctors allowed to practice

The supervision of more than 90 doctors still practising despite having drug, alcohol and health problems is in question after an independent report condemned authorities for failing to support a heavily medicated mentally ill GP and protect her patients. Christina Wong, a former junior general practice trainee at Inala, in Brisbane's southwest, was deregistered for five years in 2002 after prescribing incorrect medication and dosages and failing to complete a minor surgical procedure while clinically depressed and on six different drugs.

But a review of the case by Jonathan Phillips - a consultant psychiatrist, member of the Australian Medical Council and former Director of Mental Health in South Australia - has criticised authorities for allowing Dr Wong to keep practising despite being a regulated mental health patient at the time. "Simply, if Dr Wong, or any other person, had been impaired to the point where she needed to be a regulated patient, then she was totally unfit to be working as a medical practitioner in any setting," Dr Phillips said in his report. "At no point in my career have I ever heard of a regulated patient being allowed to continue professional duties as a medical practitioner."

Dr Phillips criticised Dr Wong's treating psychiatrist, her employer and the Queensland Medical Board, which was meant to be supervising Dr Wong under its health assessment and monitoring program.

Latest figures show more than 90 doctors are working under the program in Queensland due to various impairments involving drugs, alcohol or mental health issues. Dr Phillips said he was "uncomfortable" about the punishment meted out to Dr Wong and believed others should have shared responsibility in her case. Dr Phillips was called in by Queensland Health after repeated approaches from Dr Wong and criticism from Queensland's deputy Ombudsman.

More here





WAITING LIST COVERUP

In Australia, the "Liberal" party is the major conservative party

Queenslanders wanting to have elective surgery are being put on a waiting list to get on a waiting list, the state Liberals said. Liberal Health spokesman Bruce Flegg said the head of the Queensland Health Systems Review, Peter Forster, had confirmed the existence of the "unofficial" waiting list during public hearings in Brisbane last night. Health Minister Gordon Nuttall has denied the existence of two waiting lists.

Dr Flegg said Mr Forster's revelations had rendered Queensland's official waiting lists not worth the paper they were written on. He said it was time for Premier Peter Beattie "to cough up the true state of Queensland's waiting lists and give patients a chance to make informed choices about their healthcare". Dr Flegg said because of the dual waiting lists he believed Queenslanders could be forced to wait up to five times as long for elective surgery. "With a little honesty from Mr Beattie the real waiting lists could save lives and be published with little or no extra cost to taxpayers," he said. "Mr Beattie and his lame duck health minister have conducted a farcical media campaign insisting that Queensland's waiting lists are the best in the country when the official lists are totally meaningless and do not even remotely reflect the time taken to access medical care in Queensland."

Source

***************************

For greatest efficiency, lowest cost and maximum choice, ALL hospitals and health insurance schemes should be privately owned and run -- with government-paid vouchers for the very poor and minimal regulation.

Comments? Email me here. If there are no recent posts here, the mirror site may be more up to date. My Home Page is here or here.

***************************

Thursday, July 14, 2005

MYTHS OF SINGLE-PAYER HEALTH CARE

The basic assumptions of its advocates are wrong

When health care is made to seem "free" at the point of consumption, demand for health services will rise uncontrolled unless it is restrained by something other than cost. If market forces do not allocate health-care resources, then long waiting lists, limited access to specialized care, and government-rationed supply will characterize the health-care system. These consequences, described by John C. Goodman, Gerald L. Musgrave, and Devon M. Herrick in Lives at Risk: Single-Payer National Health Insurance Around the World, are endemic in nations that have adopted a system of single-payer national health insurance.

Lives at Risk takes head on many beliefs about nationalized health care, dubbing them "myths." Consider the myth that citizens in nations with national health insurance have a "right" to health care. Goodman et al. note, "there is no such right in any sense that people ordinarily understand the meaning of the term. What the right to care means almost everywhere is nothing more than the opportunity to get services for free." Patients only have a right to the services that the government says they can have. In Canada, for example, if you can't convince the authorities that you need an MRI scan, you are out of luck unless you can pay for it in another country. "In fact, in the 1980s some Canadian hospitals advertised in America in search of paying customers to help out with their cash-strapped budgets," according to Goodman et al. "Yet, it was illegal for Canadian citizens to pay for the same services." Until the practice was discontinued, "one could maintain that Americans had more rights in the Canadian health care system than Canadians did."

Or consider another myth, that all people in countries with national health insurance have equal access to care. The evidence simply doesn't support it. In 1980 the "Black Report" examined Britain's system of care and found that access to care had not become more equal since the National Health Service was established in the 1940s. A similar report about two decades later found that access to care had become more unequal since the Black Report. Canada has fared no better; numerous studies from the University of British Columbia show that access to care varies widely across region. Not surprisingly, the proximity of one's residence to an affluent city is one of the best indicators of access to doctors of any sort, but especially to specialists. Hospitals are more likely to have more staff per hospital bed and patients are more likely to survive treatment if they are located in an affluent region. Worse, those few who are seriously ill do not receive adequate funding, as the majority of funds go to the relatively healthy many who seek cheaper procedures. To quote Goodman et al., "Foreign governments do not merely deny lifesaving medical technology to patients under national insurance schemes. They also take money that could be spent saving lives and curing disease and spend it serving people who are not seriously ill. Often the spending has little if anything to do with health care."

Goodman et al.'s analysis falls flat, however, when the authors try to design an ideal health system. While some of their ideas would lead to greater individual liberty, others continue government's meddlesome role. For example, they note that the current tax code's treatment of health insurance means that people who do not have insurance pay a "tax penalty." They argue the taxes the uninsured pay should go to government agencies to reimburse health care costs for the uninsured. When an uninsured person decides to purchase insurance, what the government spends should be reduced by the amount the government spends per-capita. This may seem sensible in theory, but this nation's experience with Medicaid shows that government is unwilling to reduce spending, regardless of actual need. If anything, it demonstrates that state governments love to keep the Medicaid money rolling in because they find surreptitious ways to spend it on other priorities. Indeed, Goodman et al.'s desire to see a seamless transfer of tax money to government health insurance will always be weighed down by meddling of politicians, bureaucrats, and interest groups.

Despite that shortcoming, Lives at Risk is a book that should be on every conservative's bookshelf. It provides abundant intellectual ammunition to use against those agitating for national health insurance, and does so in a lively, engaging style. As the cost of health insurance continues to rise, and the likes of the New York Times op-ed page uses it to advanced socialized medicine, Lives at Risk couldn't be timelier.

Source

***************************

For greatest efficiency, lowest cost and maximum choice, ALL hospitals and health insurance schemes should be privately owned and run -- with government-paid vouchers for the very poor and minimal regulation.

Comments? Email me here. If there are no recent posts here, the mirror site may be more up to date. My Home Page is here or here.

***************************

Wednesday, July 13, 2005

VAST BUREAUCRATIC WASTE IN BRITAIN

Nearly half of the time allocated for day surgery in hospitals is lost to late starts, cancelled operations and excessive delays between patients, according to a report. A review by the Healthcare Commission has found that the average day surgery theatre is being used effectively for only 16 hours a week, placing other parts of the NHS under pressure. The report on day surgery in England concludes that at least an extra 74,000 patients a year could be treated, rather than admitted as in-patients, if hospitals were more efficient, freeing beds for more serious cases. A quarter of day surgery units were found to cancel one in ten admissions, while half of patients had not been assessed for suitability before they arrived for their operation.

Day surgery — when a patient is discharged on the same day — includes many non-emergency operations that usually require a general anaesthetic, such as hernia repairs, removal of cysts and bunions, and treating cataracts. It has many advantages for patients and the NHS. It helps to reduce waiting times, allows people to recover at home — avoiding the stress of mixing non-serious patients with the more seriously ill — it limits the risk of cross-infection and gives more cost-effective care.

In the NHS Plan published in 2000, the Government set a target that three quarters of elective admissions should be day cases. However, the commission found that only around two thirds are, some 740,000 operations a year. For some procedures the ratio of day surgery to in- patient admissions has fallen, and some trusts recorded an overall decline in day surgery. The average time allotted to day surgery was 16 hours a week, just over half the planned 30 hours, but one small unit was found to carry out on average only three hours’ work.

Anna Walker, the commission’s chief executive, said that trusts had to improve their handling of day surgery by monitoring patients more closely, cutting down on cancellations and ensuring appropriate staffing levels. “Efficiency and good patient care go hand in hand,” she said. “When operations are cancelled or when patients stay overnight for something which could be done in a single day, patients are inconvenienced and resources are wasted.” Ms Walker said that the commission would talk to the trusts, the Department of Health, other inspectorates and strategic health authorities to ensure that the lessons of the report were acted on. “The worst performers need to learn from the best,” she said.

The report comes after Patricia Hewitt, the Health Secretary, said that high levels of investment in the health service would not continue indefinitely and that trusts should strive to gain the “potential pot of gold” available from simple efficiency savings.

The study, which looked at 313 units in England, also found that one in ten day surgery units cancels more than a third of the available operating theatre sessions and many patients have operations cancelled at short notice. The study also found that overall staff numbers in day surgery units are rising faster than their activity. However, the report highlights improvements in some aspects of patient care and management of day surgery. More patients receive good written information before admission and have the opportunity to choose a convenient date for their operation.

Source

***************************

For greatest efficiency, lowest cost and maximum choice, ALL hospitals and health insurance schemes should be privately owned and run -- with government-paid vouchers for the very poor and minimal regulation.

Comments? Email me here. If there are no recent posts here, the mirror site may be more up to date. My Home Page is here or here.

***************************

Tuesday, July 12, 2005

Dismantle the FDA?

Last week, I wrote about a federal agency that most people think is indispensable. In reality, I said, the FDA regulates us to death, literally, by forbidding even dying Americans who can't be helped by established medical treatments from trying innovative therapies. But what's the alternative? Have no oversight? Let any company peddle every dubious medicine to an unsuspecting public? That sounds terrifying. Snake-oil sellers would sell all kinds of harmful stuff. That's why we created the FDA in the first place.

But wait a second. Snake oil sellers sell it anyway. I've done consumer reports on snake-oil sellers for years. Crooks and deluded optimists sell useless baldness remedies, breast enlargers and diet products while the FDA is supposedly in charge. The FDA rarely stopped even the obvious crooks. What it mostly stopped, or delayed, were the serious drug companies' attempts at genuine innovations.

Without an FDA, how would doctors and patients know which drugs were safe and effective? The same way we know which computers and restaurants are good — through newspapers, magazines and word of mouth. In a free, open society, competition gets the information out, and that protects consumers better than government command and control.

Why must we give big government so much power? Couldn't FDA scrutiny be voluntary and advisory? Companies that want government blessing would go through the whole process and, after 10 or 15 years, get the FDA's seal of approval. Those of us who are cautious would take only FDA-approved drugs. But if you had a terminal illness, you could try something that might save your life. You could try it without having to wait 15 years — without having to break your country's laws to import it illegally from Europe — without sneaking into Mexico to experiment in some dubious clinic. If I'm dying, shouldn't my government allow me the right to try whatever I want?

If FDA scrutiny were voluntary, the government agency would soon have competition. Private groups like Consumer Reports and Underwriters Laboratories (UL) might step in to compete with the FDA. The UL symbol is already on thousands of products. No government force was required. Yet even though UL certification is voluntary, its safety standards are so commonly accepted that most stores won't carry products without the UL symbol.

With such competition, the FDA might devise a ratings system ("general use," "medical guidance suggested," "patients strongly cautioned," or something like that), and drug packages would carry that information. We'd know that the government was evaluating new drugs, but government wouldn't stand between lifesaving treatments and us. Most of us, most of the time, would take the government's advice, but because it would be our choice, we could try new or risky drugs when nothing government-approved was available.

We could try a system where the FDA would review all drugs, but its approval wouldn't be needed for a drug to be sold. Private organizations might go into competition with the FDA even if its review remained mandatory. If a new drug is going to be "not yet rated" by the government for 15 years, the endorsement of an independent evaluator — even one not quite as strict as the FDA — that can deliver its opinion in three years would be valuable. Under today's FDA rule, consumers assume big government takes care of the whole issue, so we become less vigilant. The consumer is encouraged to stay asleep: Don't ask questions; just take what Big Brother approves. Yet, knowing what we know about the incompetence of government monopolies, there's little doubt that competing private groups would do the testing better, cheaper and quicker.

Any kind of FDA has its price. If all drugs have to be reviewed — even if they can be sold while under review — the cost in money and energy will keep some drugs off the market. But getting rid of the FDA's power to forbid us to try something would be a big improvement: It would mean Americans would no longer be forced to wait, and die while their government passes judgment on innovations that could save them.

Source

***************************

For greatest efficiency, lowest cost and maximum choice, ALL hospitals and health insurance schemes should be privately owned and run -- with government-paid vouchers for the very poor and minimal regulation.

Comments? Email me here. If there are no recent posts here, the mirror site may be more up to date. My Home Page is here or here.

***************************

Monday, July 11, 2005

FDA BLOCKS A BETTER SUNBLOCK

The sun sends us two kinds of ultraviolet radiation: UVA and UVB. Our suntan lotions are good at screening out the sun's UVB rays, so they help us avoid sunburn and skin cancer. But our sunscreens don't offer much protection against UVA rays, and those are the rays that eventually make us look like prunes. "Ultraviolet A light ages your skin," said Dr. Darrell Rigel, clinical professor of dermatology at New York University. "It's a longer wavelength, so it can penetrate deeper into the skin, and instead of attacking the upper layers of the skin where skin cancer often forms, it attacks the layers that give your skin its tone, its elasticity, as we call it. ... You get the lines, the wrinkles, all the things associated from aging."

But there's good news. Lotions that contain the ingredients Oxybenzone, Titanium Dioxide or Parsol 1789 block out some UVA rays. Adding a chemical called Mexoryl offers even better protection. "It produces a product which gives us almost perfect protection against sunshine," said Dr. Vincent DeLeo, chairman of dermatology at Columbia University.

People are happily protecting themselves with Mexoryl in South America, Europe, Australia and Canada, but in the USA you are forbidden to use it. The FDA won't approve it. It won't even say why. Dermatologists assume Mexoryl is just stuck in the bureaucracy. It routinely takes 12 to 15 years for a drug to get approval, and after a drug — Vioxx, for example — gets bad publicity as a health risk, the FDA gets particularly cautious.

Common sense says we should use it Mexoryl. All drugs have risks as well as benefits, and Mexoryl has been in use in other countries for 13 years. It's passed many safety tests. Yet our FDA won't even talk about it? Although Mexoryl is illegal in the United States, ABC News found it at some pharmacies. Sometimes it was hidden. You had to ask for it. It was expensive — $30 to $50. I don't fault the pharmacists; they're serving their customers. Big government is the problem

More here




Massachusetts: Hospitals cut costs for uninsured: "Two of the state's largest hospital networks, Partners HealthCare and UMass Memorial Health Care, will no longer routinely charge uninsured patients full 'sticker price' for medical care, but instead will offer 15 to 50 percent discounts, in some cases as much as the mark-downs large health insurers receive. The goals are to provide a price break for uninsured patients who earn too much money to qualify for state assistance and to make collecting payments from them easier. The new policies come at a time when hospitals across the US face criticism and lawsuits over aggressive billing methods and for routinely charging the uninsured far more for treatment than they do health insurers. Executives at Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center said they routinely give patients discounts."

***************************

For greatest efficiency, lowest cost and maximum choice, ALL hospitals and health insurance schemes should be privately owned and run -- with government-paid vouchers for the very poor and minimal regulation.

Comments? Email me here. If there are no recent posts here, the mirror site may be more up to date. My Home Page is here or here.

***************************

Sunday, July 10, 2005

THE FIRST OFFICIAL ANNOUNCEMENT OF MEDICAL VOUCHERS

That I know of, anyway. From Australia:

Queensland Health Minister Gordon Nuttall has been embroiled in the so-called "Dr Death" scandal after a senior bureaucrat yesterday disputed his claim that he had never been warned about problems with overseas-trained doctors. Three months after telling a local newspaper his department had not briefed him on concerns over the competencies of overseas-trained doctors before the furore erupted over Indian-trained American surgeon Jayant Patel, Mr Nuttall yesterday stood by his comments in a parliamentary budget estimates hearing. Under questioning from Opposition health spokesman Stuart Copeland, Mr Nuttall at first agreed to let the department's senior executive director of health services, John Scott, and director-general Steve Buckland elaborate on how he had not received a briefing on the issue.

But Dr Buckland was never given the opportunity to speak on the issue as Dr Scott, who plans to leave the department and return to medicine, directly contradicted the minister. "Certainly, my understanding is that in discussions that I had had with the minister's office and with the minister in the past, either on the basis of one-to-one or in concert with other officers of Queensland Health, the issues had been raised," Dr Scott told the hearing. "But I think also that there have been other meetings in the past with outside agencies like the AMA or the Rural Doctors where I understood that those issues had been raised as well."

Mr Nuttall - who took the portfolio in February last year - accused Mr Copeland of trying to drive a wedge between him and the department and said the outside agencies should have made their concerns known to the Queensland Medical Board. "The issue around the competencies of overseas-trained doctors was never brought to my attention," Mr Nuttall said. But Mr Copeland said Mr Nuttall had put up a "fanciful charade that he did not know" and should be sacked.

Outside the hearing, Mr Nuttall denied that he or Dr Scott were lying, saying only that they had differing views. The Supreme Court will on Monday hold a directions hearing that may halt the "Dr Death" inquiry as Bundaberg Base Hospital's director of medical services, Darren Keating, has sought to shut it down.

In an effort to overcome the doctor shortage, which has led to Queensland's reliance on overseas-trained doctors, Mr Nuttall has offered to co-locate doctors at regional public hospitals free of charge and will test the arrangement at four sites in Queensland. He has also proposed periodical assessment of doctors' skills, a stronger partnership between the public and private sectors and a voucher system whereby patients could choose where to undergo treatment but still have the bills paid by the state.

Source

***************************

For greatest efficiency, lowest cost and maximum choice, ALL hospitals and health insurance schemes should be privately owned and run -- with government-paid vouchers for the very poor and minimal regulation.

Comments? Email me here. If there are no recent posts here, the mirror site may be more up to date. My Home Page is here or here.

***************************

Saturday, July 09, 2005

AUSTRALIA: A STATE HEALTH DEPT. DEFRAUDS THE FEDS

How low-life can a public medicine system get?

Queensland Health is being investigated for Medicare fraud which doctors say could amount to "tens of millions of dollars" each year dishonestly obtained from the Federal Government, with senior staff potentially facing criminal prosecution. The scheme involves getting medical specialists employed by Queensland Health to allow other doctors, mostly young registrars, to use their Medicare provider numbers and bill the Federal Government for services provided. Medicare laws make it illegal for any person to bill the commonwealth for a service that was not provided directly by the holder of the provider number.

Documents provided to The Courier-Mail indicate the fraud could be widespread in Queensland Health, with a number of confidential emails from senior Queensland Health staff encouraging the practice and advising it is used in a number of Queensland hospitals. Another email outlines that administration officers "were instructed to get bulk-billing forms signed before the patient was seen", despite doctors advising that the practice was illegal. A complaint to the Commonwealth Health Insurance Commission by one doctor states "billing has been initiated without my consent".

A spokeswoman for federal Health Minister Tony Abbott last night confirmed the federal Health Department was aware of a number of potential alleged breaches by Queensland Health of the Australian Healthcare Agreement. "The Government is very concerned about these and the department has been actively pursuing these with Queensland Health," the spokeswoman said.

Senior staff who complained to Queensland Health that the practice was illegal have subsequently complained of "bullying, harassment, intimidation, discrimination and vilification". A number of formal complaints have been lodged with the HIC and the federal Department of Health.

Liberal health spokesman Bruce Flegg said he had spoken to the doctors concerned and was satisfied that the scheme constituted "a systematic fraud of Medicare". Dr Flegg said doctors who had expressed their concerns had their "salaries slashed for refusing to break federal laws". "It's an appalling way to treat Queensland Health staff by placing them at risk of serious criminal charges," Dr Flegg said.

After inspecting the documents obtained by The Courier-Mail, Australian Medical Association Queensland president Steve Hambleton said he was aware of the practice and had previously complained about it to Mr Abbott. "If the public hospital system is facilitating patient-signed Medicare vouchers without seeing the doctor whose provider number it is, it is both illegal and reprehensible," Dr Hambleton said. "A doctor must see a patient to raise a fee, otherwise it is fraud."

A Queensland Health spokesman said last night that allegations of this nature should be referred to the HIC for investigation.

Source





How to improve Medicaid for minorities: "Ethnic minorities in America, particularly African-Americans, are generally less healthy than whites and suffer from reduced access to quality health care services. This should be unacceptable in the richest and most advanced country on the planet. There are a range of socioeconomic and cultural reasons for these troubling findings, but one reason in particular typically escapes scrutiny: minorities' disproportionate representation in the outdated and bureaucratic Medicaid program."

***************************

For greatest efficiency, lowest cost and maximum choice, ALL hospitals and health insurance schemes should be privately owned and run -- with government-paid vouchers for the very poor and minimal regulation.

Comments? Email me here. If there are no recent posts here, the mirror site may be more up to date. My Home Page is here or here.

***************************

Friday, July 08, 2005

LOCKED UP INSTEAD OF BEING TREATED!

Another triumph of sensitive and caring public medicine in Australia. Would a fee-paying ciustomer get treated like this?

A hero bus driver was mistakenly locked in a hospital mental health ward after being offered counselling. Greg Gow, 54, of Bray Park, in Brisbane's north, had gone to the Royal Brisbane and Women's Hospital only to get treatment for a broken rib. But he ended up sitting in a locked room for four hours with potentially dangerous drug addicts and mental-health patients. "I wanted to get out but I was told I had to stay," he told The Sunday Mail.

Mr Gow has been widely praised for his actions when the bus he was driving in August suffered a mechanical problem. The bus, carrying 37 passengers including 16 children, narrowly missed a pole before crashing through bushes and a chain-wire fence and stopping against the side of a Bray Park house. No one suffered major injuries and Mr Gow was praised as a hero for his presence of mind in averting a tragedy. He was even mentioned in Parliament for his actions and he has been nominated for The Sunday Mail and The Courier-Mail Pride of Australia medal for courage. A witness described Mr Gow as "remarkable". Students on the bus signed a letter expressing their gratitude to him.

Mr Gow said he was still upset by his treatment at the hospital, where he was forced to endure four hours sitting on a hard chair with his broken rib in Ward GB – the acute mental health assessment unit. Mr Gow said the drama began when he accepted an offer to see a trauma counsellor and was taken with his wife Amy to Ward GB. "Here I was, supposed to be a hero, and I was stuck in this ward with drug addicts and people with mental illness," he said. "One guy beside me had an army jacket on and staff frisked him and found he had a screwdriver. "I just couldn't believe what was happening. I wanted to get out but I was told I had to stay. I could walk in but I couldn't walk out. "I was really shaken up by the bus accident and this was the last thing I needed. When the doctor offered me counselling, I didn't know they meant to take me there."

Mrs Gow, 55, said she realised they had been taken to the mental health ward only when the door to the ward locked behind them. "It didn't click at first where we were," she said. "Then the door locked shut behind us and we looked around at the other patients and it just didn't look right. I asked if we could go home and I was told that I could leave but Greg had to stay. It was unbelievable. I was so shocked. The whole public health system really needs an overhaul – it really needs to be a priority and it just doesn't seem to be."

Mr Gow said he was allowed out only when a friend also waiting with him became angry with staff and demanded he be released. Mr Gow was finally allowed to go home about 10.45pm – four hours later – without any counselling.

Mr Gow's local member of parliament, Labor's Linda Lavarch, wrote to Health Minister Gordon Nuttall on the Gows' behalf requesting an explanation and apology. "I really felt for them," Mrs Lavarch said. "They felt they were treated with no compassion and that there was a lack of communication. They were certainly distressed about how they felt they were treated.

Source

***************************

For greatest efficiency, lowest cost and maximum choice, ALL hospitals and health insurance schemes should be privately owned and run -- with government-paid vouchers for the very poor and minimal regulation.

Comments? Email me here. If there are no recent posts here, the mirror site may be more up to date. My Home Page is here or here.

***************************

Thursday, July 07, 2005

BRITISH LEFT EMBRACES PRIVATE MEDICINE

Post lifted from the Adam Smith blog

Readers of the leftish Guardian newspaper must been choking on their cornflakes [muesli?] as they read UK Health Secretary Patricia Hewitt's article saying why private healthcare is here to stay.

Today, there are three reasons why we are using the independent sector to provide some treatments for NHS patients: to increase capacity, support patient choice and help improve value for money by raising productivity and innovation.


Hewitt told the 'forces of conservatism' who want to block NHS reform that the state-run health system cannot meet the targets to cut waiting times on its own. And she praised the ingenuity of private providers, who now deliver a rising volume of state-funded operations.

Independent providers have given the NHS mobile units for cataract operations and MRI scans, taking services to communities most in need. For example, waiting times for MRI scans in Barnsley have fallen from 20 weeks to five. It is striking how NHS waiting lists miraculously shrink as clinicians reorganise their ways of working when faced with the prospect of an independent treatment centre down the road or patients being sent to a private hospital.


Competition is a wonderful thing, isn't it? But even so, Hewitt still wants to put a cap on it, reassuring her readers that by 2008, the £850m spent on private-sector treatment will still be less than 1% of the NHS budget. Why not follow the advice of our new health report and make it 100%? Could it be that a New Labour government still needs Old Labour votes?

***************************

For greatest efficiency, lowest cost and maximum choice, ALL hospitals and health insurance schemes should be privately owned and run -- with government-paid vouchers for the very poor and minimal regulation.

Comments? Email me here. If there are no recent posts here, the mirror site may be more up to date. My Home Page is here or here.

***************************

Wednesday, July 06, 2005

FRUSTRATED AUSTRALIAN PATIENTS GOING TO INDIA FOR SURGERY TOO

Sick Australians are playing Russian roulette with their health by travelling overseas for cut-price surgery. [They play Russian roulette by going to Australian public hospitals too] Foreign hospitals – once seen as an option only for plastic surgery – are now operating on a fast-growing number of Australians wanting standard medical procedures. Knee and hip operations, prostate surgery, dental work and ear, nose and throat surgery can all be done instantly – instead of waiting lists of five years or more in Queensland. Australian "medical tourists" are travelling to India, Dubai, Singapore, Malaysia and Thailand, where some hospitals advertise "First World service at Third World cost".

Brisbane company International Medical Tours, which organises holidays to Thailand for cosmetic surgery, says demand for other treatment is so high it is branching out into tours offering elective surgery. IMT managing director John Uittenbogaard said inquiries for knee and hip operations had soared.

Figures obtained by The Sunday Mail show Bangkok's 550-bed Bumrungrad Hospital treated more than 5100 Australian passport-holders for elective or cosmetic surgery in the first five months of this year.

But Australian Society of Plastic Surgeons president Dr Norm Olbourne said the thousands of dollars that patients saved overseas could come at a cost. "I'm flabbergasted that people would play Russian roulette with their health," Dr Olbourne said. [Better to stay in Australia and get treated by "Dr. Death", I guess] Dr Olbourne said there was no after-care and many times people returned to Australia with problems they expected to be fixed on Medicare.

Australian Medical Association state president-elect Dr Steve Hambleton said while there were excellent surgeons and clinical schools in Asia, there were risks. They included the difficulty of judging quality of service and hospital equipment standards and the lack of post-operative care, Dr Hambleton said.

Liberal state health spokesman Bruce Flegg said long waiting lists for elective surgery would drive more Queenslanders overseas. Dr Flegg said that some already were so desperate they were mortgaging their homes for local private operations and would be tempted by cheaper and faster overseas treatments. "Our system is failing and we don't have the capability of providing the necessary medical treatment for the whole population," he said.

Dr Hambleton said there were still lengthy waiting lists for knee, hip and eye surgery and the State Government should offer realistic waiting lists so people could make informed choices before going overseas.

Dean of Surgery at the University of Sydney, Professor Andrew Coats, said the number of Australians seeking surgery overseas would increase as part of the globalisation of trade. Prof Coats said Dubai had major healthcare groups of first world standards offering high-volume, high-technology medicine. "You can roll it up into a holiday and still come back with savings," he said.

A spokesman for Queensland Health Minister Gordon Nuttall urged people to be cautious about seeking surgery overseas. The Government committed $130 million over three years to bring down elective surgery waiting lists. The number of Queensland's private hospital admissions is 25 per cent higher than the national average and the State spends the least on health of any State or territory. But Queensland has better elective surgery waiting times than any other state, according to a Commonwealth Department of Health and Ageing Report.

Simon van Putten flew to India to have a knee reconstruction rather than wait possibly years to have the operation in Toowoomba Hospital.
The retired Stanthorpe boilermaker, 67, was so pleased with his operation two months ago, he is considering returning for surgery on the other knee.
Mr van Putten said that while he was driven to go to India by the waiting time in Queensland, rather than the cost, there were huge savings to be made. He spent $8600, including airfare and medical fees, and says in Australia the same procedure would have cost him at least $12,000 as an intermediate patient (private patient in a public ward) and up to $27,000 by going private.

Mr van Putten, who did not have private insurance, was told he was on only "a waiting list for the waiting list". He realised the risks involved, but he researched the hospital and surgeons before he went.

Within 24 hours of contacting the hospital by email, he was discussing his case with an Indian surgeon. Mr van Putten and his female companion stayed in a large air-conditioned room in the international section of the Apollo Hospital in Chennai. "The nursing was unbelievable – nurses in every two hours, sisters every three hours and the director of nursing at least once a day," Mr van Putten said

Source

***************************

For greatest efficiency, lowest cost and maximum choice, ALL hospitals and health insurance schemes should be privately owned and run -- with government-paid vouchers for the very poor and minimal regulation.

Comments? Email me here. If there are no recent posts here, the mirror site may be more up to date. My Home Page is here or here.

***************************

Tuesday, July 05, 2005

PAPERWORK OBSESSION TRUMPS MEDICAL CARE

The latest news from Australia in the "Dr. Death" saga

The Jayant Patel debacle was a disaster waiting to happen because of the fundamental systemic failure that exists in Queensland Health, a former Bundaberg Hospital executive said yesterday. Dr Brian Thiele, an internationally acclaimed vascular surgeon who worked as Bundaberg's director of medical services from 1994-1999, launched a scathing attack on his former employer yesterday but emphasised his overriding desire was to see the system fixed. The private specialist ended all involvement with the hospital in 2004 because of his frustrations.

Dr Thiele said although he had little direct contact with Dr Patel during his tenure, the present fiasco was symptomatic of a downward slide in the health system he believed started when management began referring to patients as "clients".

He said in one of his few encounters with Dr Patel his impression was that the surgeon was a bit "gung ho", and Dr Thiele was distressed that despite his own extensive surgical experience in the US no one asked him to check Dr Patel's credentials. "It's a terrible shame that the fundamental phone call was not made to check his referees or where he trained." Dr Thiele also said the department's liking of paperwork and compiling reports was destructive because it often prevented the truth from emerging. He said employees were reluctant to discuss real problems because of a "control freak mentality" in the bureaucracy that only encouraged good news. "In Queensland Health there is a very strong culture of pleasing the boss," Dr Thiele said. "Somebody needs to go through Queensland Health with a big knife and be absolutely ruthless."

But while Dr Thiele was unrelenting in his criticism of the administration, he praised the "huge repository" of individual talent in the system. He said those employees were the ones who would eventually bear the brunt of fixing the problems.

The state's fiscal arrangements which saw Treasury dictate how much money would go to health services also came under attack. "My experience was Treasury exerted a very powerful degree of control over the Department of Health. The politicisation has become so intense it has a negative effect," Dr Thiele said. He said he could not apportion blame to individuals in the hospital hierarchy because they, too, were victims of the system. But he claimed the hospital's existing District Health Council, a body that oversees administration at a local level, was "a joke" because it had no authority to delve into hospital issues. He said staff and public confidence could be boosted by wresting control of the hospital out of the hands of Queensland Health and delivering it back to the community.

Dr Thiele's blunt assessment sparked a spontaneous round of applause from the public gallery when he finished his evidence yesterday afternoon. Inquiry chairman Tony Morris, QC, thanked Dr Thiele for his honesty and said the public reaction spoke for itself.

Source

***************************

For greatest efficiency, lowest cost and maximum choice, ALL hospitals and health insurance schemes should be privately owned and run -- with government-paid vouchers for the very poor and minimal regulation.

Comments? Email me here. If there are no recent posts here, the mirror site may be more up to date. My Home Page is here or here.

***************************

Monday, July 04, 2005

A STATE-RUN HEALTH BUREAUCRACY FINALLY COLLAPSES

A federal judge, saying he was acting urgently to stop the needless deaths of inmates because of medical malfeasance, ordered Thursday that a receiver take control of California's prison health care system and correct what he called deplorable conditions. Experts said the order by U.S. District Judge Thelton Henderson of San Francisco was unprecedented in its scope given that the prison system provides health care to roughly 164,000 inmates at an annual cost of $1.1 billion. The order also was an embarrassing blow for the administration of Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger, which has promised to deliver major medical reforms for nearly two years but, Henderson said, has utterly failed.

The prison medical system offered "at times outright depravity, and I intentionally call it that," said Henderson. He also said the need for action was so dire that he might appoint a temporary receiver in just weeks to at least begin to limit the harm to inmates from the poor medical care before a permanent receiver is put in place.

Inmate families and those who have long fought for change in the prisons were ebullient. "It's certainly everything we asked for," said Donald Specter, head of the Prison Law Office, the prisoner rights group that filed the suit on which the judge was acting. Henderson said he would begin the process of selecting a receiver and defining his or her powers in consultation with state officials and the inmates' lawyers. The decision followed weeks of testimony from medical experts that Henderson described as horrifying in its depiction of barbaric medical conditions in some prisons, resulting in as many as 64 preventable deaths of inmates a year and injury to countless others.

The state's attorneys have never even bothered to fight those characterizations or the need for federal intervention in spite of their damning reflection on prison managers. "This is humiliating," said James Jacobs, a law professor at New York University and an expert on court intervention in prison management. "What's extreme here is, it's like the judge is saying to the state, 'I'm totally giving up on you -- you are unwilling or unable to do this on your own.' " Indeed, top prisons officials for months have admitted the department was incapable of administering the system, a massive and complex medical program stretching the length of the state, often in remote locations.

The state's lawyers have focused principally on trying to limit the power of the receiver. "Nobody can do this by themselves," said Bruce Slavin, the prison system's general counsel. "A receiver can help us do what we want to do faster. " The unions representing prison health workers, who have been at war with the prisons department, in part over who was responsible for conditions in the prisons, said they were thrilled at the judge's decision. The unions had jointly filed a brief in favor of the appointment of a receiver. "All the unions are more than willing to work with the receiver," said Gary Robinson, the executive director of the Union of American Physicians and Dentists. "We think the department is incapable of the reforms that are necessary. The judge's position is absolutely correct. The management has been incompetent."

Michael Jacobson, the director of the Vera Institute of Justice and the former head of New York City's jails, said the receiver should begin a process of deep changes reaching into all levels of management and the culture inside the prisons. "Nothing is going to happen for some years," he said. "This has to be a catalyst for longer-term structural changes. The potential implications of this are just so humongous." Henderson said appointing a receiver was a last resort but was a result of the Schwarzenegger administration's refusal to comply with his orders to improve the appalling quality of prison medical care.

A federal injunction has been in place for three years requiring phased-in medical improvements at each state prison, but the Corrections Department has met none of the goals. In one case described by court-appointed experts, an inmate's spine was injured in a fight. A prison doctor refused to believe the inmate's claim that he couldn't move, and the doctor wrenched the inmate's head and neck during the examination, aggravating his paralysis.

In a case at San Quentin in January, an inmate reported to the infirmary seeking emergency treatment with signs of shock. A doctor already under investigation for two previous suspicious deaths prescribed antibiotics for what he said was bronchitis. When the inmate collapsed on the way back to his cell, the guards brought him back. The doctor ordered that the inmate be given intravenous fluids, but when the staff could not find a vein, the inmate was simply returned to his cell. The inmate died the next day from a serious lung ailment.

He indicated that the receiver was likely to have the ability, at the least, to fire incompetent doctors and hire quickly to fill the more than 150 positions that have been vacant for years and to order construction to improve conditions in the state's 33 prisons. "This is no panacea," said Jacobs. "It's a staggeringly large job."

Henderson was clear that the process is likely to be long and arduous because of the depth of the problems. In spite of condemning incompetent doctors described in earlier testimony, Henderson went out of his way to praise the rank-and-file prison health workers while excoriating prison managers. "It's also become apparent that the state has no effective management structure to offer health care," Henderson said. He added later in his comments from the bench, "My decision to establish a receivership is just a start."

Source

***************************

For greatest efficiency, lowest cost and maximum choice, ALL hospitals and health insurance schemes should be privately owned and run -- with government-paid vouchers for the very poor and minimal regulation.

Comments? Email me here. If there are no recent posts here, the mirror site may be more up to date. My Home Page is here or here.

***************************

Sunday, July 03, 2005

Health problem is monopoly, not management

(Post lifted from the Adam Smith blog)

State hospitals and clinics in England went £140m into the red last year, with a quarter of them failing to meet their legal requirement to balance the books, government audit bodies have revealed. That's despite billions more of taxpayers' money going into them. Health Secretary Patricia Hewitt says they need better financial management.

No, that's not the answer. State healthcare is overflowing with managers. But since it's a monopoly there is no incentive for them to excel at the job. And doctors ignore them anyway, claiming 'clinical freedom'.

Last night the authors of our new health report gave a seminar at the Adam Smith Institute. They support the ideals of the National Health Service and many of its features. But along with many in the audience they were scathing about the ability of the NHS to deliver good, joined-up patient care. Sorry, they said, but this 1948 state monopoly has to go. Sure, the government should pay for a lot of health care. But we need state-run hospitals about as much as we need state-run supermarkets or clothes shops. People actually get a much better service if there is innovation and choice in its supply.

I was surprised just how directly people were talking. Even some government officials there were nodding agreement with this radical view. Or maybe not so radical, these days. People feel the extra billions being spent, but see no change in how the NHS is run. Shiny new buildings, same squalid service.

The NHS has long been a national icon, immune from criticism. Not now. The mood is growing that the 1948 monopoly model has had its chips. No amount of new management can save it. Better to break it up and make every hospital and clinic independent. One might even say, privatize them.

***************************

For greatest efficiency, lowest cost and maximum choice, ALL hospitals and health insurance schemes should be privately owned and run -- with government-paid vouchers for the very poor and minimal regulation.

Comments? Email me here. If there are no recent posts here, the mirror site may be more up to date. My Home Page is here or here.

***************************

Saturday, July 02, 2005

BRITISH NHS HOSPITALS A "WAR ZONE"

A young doctor yesterday accused the Government of turning her hospital into a "war zone" as Patricia Hewitt became the first Health Secretary to address the British Medical Association in its 173-year history. Jennie Blackwell, a senior house officer, told Ms Hewitt that she and her colleagues dreaded going to work because Government targets had left her unit completely overwhelmed by patients. Describing chaotic pressures that left patients "strewn all round the unit", Dr Blackwell, who is a member of the Junior Doctors' Committee, said that people were often forced to wait for hours on trolleys in the corridor before they were treated.

Dr Blackwell, 27, took Ms Hewitt to task over the target that 98 per cent of accident and emergency patients should be seen and treated within four hours. She said that many patients were being moved from A&E [i.e. ER] into her medical assessment unit before they had been treated properly, simply to meet the target.

She added that life-threatening illnesses were getting overlooked as overstretched doctors struggled to cope, while paramedics were left waiting with patients instead of responding to new emergencies. "It's like a war zone," Dr Blackwell said of her hospital, which she declined to name but said was in the North West. "We have patients strewn all over the unit, sitting in non medical areas with serious medical conditions. It is frankly dangerous that we don't have the facilities to cope with these things. Please, please, please reduce this target as it's awful for patients and awful for us."

Speaking at the BMA's conference in Manchester - an experience she likened to "Daniel entering the lion's den" - Ms Hewitt said that targets were needed to help to achieve much-needed NHS improvements. "I'm not going to resile from the importance of those new, more limited number of targets," she said. "Although they are crude, they are helping to achieve a much needed improvement in the services."

Jonathan Fielden, the deputy chairman of the BMA's consultants committee, said that the problem had been raised by other doctors across the UK but he did not believe it was common. "It is a particular issue where NHS trusts focus on a target rather than the whole process of care for a patient," he said.

Source




Export restrictions placed on Canada by U.S. drug companies are working: "Canada intends to ban the bulk of export prescriptions to the United States and other countries to try to control Internet pharmacies, the health minister said Tuesday. Health Minister Ujjal Dosanjh said he must ensure Canadians continue to have access to an adequate supply of safe and affordable prescription drugs and would launch initiatives, including legislative and regulatory changes, to protect the supply and safety of Canada's drugs. Sales of the drugs have become popular with Americans seeking cheaper medicine. President Bush's administration opposes the prescription drug imports, and federal regulators warn they cannot guarantee the safety of drugs from outside U.S. borders. But Canada has dismissed concerns about the safety of drugs sold in Canada, saying Canada's regulatory regime was tougher than the U.S. one."

***************************

For greatest efficiency, lowest cost and maximum choice, ALL hospitals and health insurance schemes should be privately owned and run -- with government-paid vouchers for the very poor and minimal regulation.

Comments? Email me here. If there are no recent posts here, the mirror site may be more up to date. My Home Page is here or here.

***************************

Friday, July 01, 2005

THE OLD, OLD SOCIALIST STORY: WAITING LISTS FOR TREATMENT GROWING EVER LONGER:

As the health bureaucrats get more and more numerous

Patients throughout Australia are waiting longer to have elective surgery than they were six years ago. The worst performers were Tasmania and the ACT, where only 59 per cent and 72 per cent of patients were treated within what the federal Government recommends is a clinically appropriate time. The government report, the State of Our Public Hospitals 2003-04, found the number of patients who had elective surgery within the clinically appropriate time fell in all states and territories compared with 1998-99.

The waiting times for common procedures such as total knee replacements and cataract surgery varied significantly around the country. In Queensland, patients waited an average 68 days for a total knee replacement compared with 432 days in Tasmania. Cataract surgery was usually performed within 40 days in Queensland and 393 days in Tasmania. The report says many people mistakenly thought the term "elective surgery" meant choosing to undergo a non-essential or optional surgical procedure. "Much of the elective surgery undertaken in Australia's hospitals is urgent and critical, such as coronary bypass operations and hip replacements, which are clearly necessary and often fundamental for a person's well-being," it says.

Health Minister Tony Abbott said the Government was taking pressure off the public health system through private health incentives that had lead to a jump in private health membership from 30per cent of Australians in 1999 to 43 per cent last year. However, according to the report, patients with private health insurance were increasingly going to public hospitals for treatment. The number of private patients admitted to public hospitals increased from 321,000 patients in 1998-99, or 8 per cent of all public hospitals admissions, to about 360,000, or 12 per cent, in 2003-04.

A spokeswoman for Mr Abbott said admissions to private hospitals was growing at a much faster rate than in public hospitals. "Something like 56 per cent of all surgery now is done in private hospitals. If that all had to be done in public hospitals can you imagine their elective surgery lists," she said. "Every person who is treated in a private hospital is one less person who has to be treated in a public hospitals."

Australian Healthcare Association executive director Prue Power, whose organisation represents public hospitals, said the public sector was struggling to cope.

More here





AND WHO NEEDS AN AMBULANCE ANYWAY?

In Britain you'd better not

Ambulance response times for potentially serious cases will rise under an overhaul of the service. A report detailing plans for a 25 per cent reduction in ambulance visits to accident and emergency departments, with more treatment at home by paramedics, will be published by ministers today. The response times for those with life-threatening conditions such as severe chest pain (category A) will be eight minutes from the time the 999 call is connected. But for other potentially life-threatening conditions such as acute abdominal pain (category B) it will rise from 14 minutes in urban areas to 19 minutes. In rural areas it will remain at 19 minutes. For non-urgent cases such as small cuts, knee injuries and sprains (category C) the response times will be up to local services.

Under the reforms, to be phased in from April next year, fully equipped ambulances will mainly be used for the most critical cases. The remainder of the 999 calls will be dealt with by emergency paramedics, driving people carriers, who will be able to treat many people at home, avoiding a hospital visit.

The report says that 10 per cent of all calls are from older people who have fallen in their homes, some of whom have suffered no injury. The paramedics would be able to take a blood sample, prescribe drugs, treat asthma and diabetes and refer patients to GPs. The Government believes that up to one million people a year are taken to hospital unnecessarily.

Ministers conceded that the number of fully equipped ambulances would fall as a proportion of the overall fleet in the next few years as the number of new emergency paramedics increased. Lord Warner said: "We will make sure that the ambulance services are able to respond to life-threatening emergencies as quickly as possible

More here

***************************

For greatest efficiency, lowest cost and maximum choice, ALL hospitals and health insurance schemes should be privately owned and run -- with government-paid vouchers for the very poor and minimal regulation.

Comments? Email me here. If there are no recent posts here, the mirror site may be more up to date. My Home Page is here or here.

***************************

Thursday, June 30, 2005

RESTORE PRICE-AWARENESS BY MAKING TAX FAIRER

Prices are advertised everywhere. From newspapers to billboards to websites, we are forever being told how much things cost. Want to buy contact lenses? A cruise to Alaska? A pedicure? The price of almost any product or service is readily available, and vendors vie for business by keeping their prices competitive.

But not when it comes to health care. How much does your local hospital charge to deliver a baby? Which blood pressure drugs are the most affordable? What is the going rate for a pediatric checkup? Most of us couldn't begin to answer such questions. Hospitals and physicians rarely advertise their rates because patients rarely care to learn them. For the majority of Americans under age 65, medical bills are something insurance companies take care of. Few patients have any incentive to focus on price, so few health care providers have any incentive to compete on price. Result: ever-higher health care costs, leading to ever-higher insurance costs.

It may seem natural to rely on insurance to pay for ordinary health needs, but it isn't. After all, we don't use auto insurance for tuneups or tires. Homeowners insurance doesn't cover paint jobs or new applicances. Those kinds of costs we pay out of pocket, which is why we do things like get written estimates or check Consumer Reports. When we're footing the bill, price and value matter.

So why are medical expenses different? The answer has nothing to do with health care -- and everything to do with the tax code. For more than 60 years, federal law has excluded the value of employer-provided health insurance from the employee's taxable income. Buy your own health insurance, and you pay for it with after-tax dollars. Get health insurance through your employer, and it's tax-free. This policy dates from World War II, when a labor shortage caused by wage controls led employers to offer health insurance in lieu of cash as a way to recruit and retain employees. When the IRS agreed to go along with the legal fiction that this employer-paid benefit wasn't really income, it triggered a radical -- but unintended -- change in the way Americans paid for health care. Within 10 years, the number of people with health insurance had soared from fewer than 3 million to nearly 80 million. And instead of the limited coverage that used to be the norm -- typically, only hospitalization was insured against -- health insurance gradually expanded to cover day-to-day medical costs.

Economics and human nature don't change when it comes to health care: Insulate consumers from the cost of the choices they make, and those choices tend to become more extravagant and oblivious to price. Give them a reason to care about the bottom line, and their spending becomes more cost-conscious and careful. Which is why real health care reform starts with tax reform.

After 60 years, it's too late to repeal the tax shelter for employer-provided health insurance. But why not extend that favorable treatment to individuals' own health expenditures? The goal should be to alter the way people buy health care by giving them a financial stake in its cost. That would be the result of leveling the playing field between medical benefits provided by an employer and those that taxpayers provide for themselves.

As John Cogan and Daniel Kessler of Stanford's Hoover Institution and R. Glenn Hubbard of Columbia have proposed, all medical expenses should be made tax-deductible for everyone, so long as they are covered for catastrophic health care. Medical expenses would include an employee's contribution to employer-provided insurance or the cost of insurance purchased individually, as well as out-of-pocket spending. Taxpayers would be free to stick with their employer's expensive health plan if they wished, but now there would be no tax incentive to do so. Most employees would choose to switch to a cheaper health plan with higher deductibles and co-pays. Employers' health care costs would fall sharply, and market pressures would ensure that those savings returned to employees in the form of higher wages.

Higher co-pays will make consumers "more cost-conscious and more willing to take greater control of health care decisions," write Cogan, Kessler, and Hubbard. "Ultimately, consumers will make better health care choices, achieving improved . . . outcomes and considerable savings." Based on RAND Corporation research, they estimate that making medical expenses deductible would reduce health care spending by $40 billion -- all without forcing a single benefit cut on anyone.

With health care no longer a function of employment, concerns about portability would vanish -- your benefits would go wherever you went. Because insurance would be more affordable, fewer Americans would remain uninsured. Above all, consumers would be in charge of their own health care. As a result, providers would compete for their business and prices would come out of the shadows. Would it be the last word in health care reform? Far from it. But it would make a terrific first step.

From Jeff Jacoby




Comment from a medical specialist on yesterday's post:

"Great story on clinics at Target etc. No doubt these clinics will refer difficult cases to an ER - liability would be high if they didn't. But the majority of ER visits could be handled by a nurse anyway. But don't count liability out - Target will be a bigger target than any hospital (pun intended) - the deep pockets of Target or Wal Mart will be irresistable to legal predators, which may be the undoing of this common sense solution to long lines in doctors' offices and ERs.

But such clinics will NEVER be viable in the inner city. Our ER is totally overwhelmed by mental patients -- many of them "homeless" who simply want shelter and a handout, but ER doctors are afraid of just telling them to "get lost" because of liability -- most know how to pretend they are suicidal, guaranteeing them food, shelter, etc. So everyone else waits in line".

***************************

For greatest efficiency, lowest cost and maximum choice, ALL hospitals and health insurance schemes should be privately owned and run -- with government-paid vouchers for the very poor and minimal regulation.

Comments? Email me here. If there are no recent posts here, the mirror site may be more up to date. My Home Page is here or here.

***************************

Wednesday, June 29, 2005

New Kind of Clinic in Supermarkets, Stores Offering Swift Treatment for Simple Illnesses

When Ann Theisen's 6-year-old daughter, Hannah, had a sore throat, she didn't take the little girl to the family doctor. Instead, she went to the Cub Foods store down the street from her house, lured by the prospect of faster treatment at a MinuteClinic tucked into a corner of the supermarket. Within about 15 minutes -- no appointment necessary -- they were seen and had the results of a rapid strep test: negative. "It's the convenience factor," Theisen said.

MinuteClinic, based in Minneapolis, is on the leading edge of a new kind of clinic that offers swift treatment for simple illnesses. MinuteClinic operates in 22 locations in the Twin Cities and Baltimore, most of them in Target Corp., the nation's second-largest discount department store chain; Cub Foods, operated by grocery retailer Supervalu Inc.; and CVS Corp. stores. The company has big plans to open more than 80 clinics in 12 major metropolitan areas east of the Rockies by year's end, and to push westward next year. "The demand for this is so amazingly consistent," said chief executive Michael Howe, the former Arby's head who joined the company earlier this month. "It's really something we've all been looking for -- making health care a little more convenient and affordable for everyone."

At the quick-service clinics, nurse practitioners diagnose and treat strep throat, pink eye, bronchitis and other common ailments. Howe and other MinuteClinic executives say their business is to health care what ATMs are to banks -- making ordinary transactions easier while freeing up traditional providers for more complicated cases. It is a low-tech, low-cost innovation that could catch on, said Matt Eyring of Innosight, a consulting company that tracks health care trends. The average MinuteClinic visit does not require an appointment and costs the patient less than $50, Howe said. The cost can be shaved down to the same co-payment as a doctor visit under several major health insurance plans. "This is something that makes medicine much more available to consumers," Eyring said. "This kind of service will spread."

MinuteClinic was founded five years ago. Its competitors include MediMin, which operates in the Cleveland area, FastCare in Louisville, Ky., and QuickClinic in Akron, Ohio. Howe would not disclose MinuteClinic's annual sales or profit. Each clinic treats an average of 30 to 35 patients a day, he said. More than three-quarters of those who visit the clinics have health insurance. Major plans -- including Blue Cross Blue Shield, UnitedHealth Group and Medicare -- include MinuteClinics in their networks in the Twin Cities.

Some employers have lowered insurance co-payments for MinuteClinic visits because they cost less than traditional doctor visits, Howe said. And some companies -- including electronics retailer Best Buy Co., Carlson Cos. and medical device maker Guidant Corp. -- host MinuteClinic operations at their corporate locations in the Twin Cities.

The American Medical Association and the American Hospital Association are wary of the trend. What is best for patients, they say, is an ongoing relationship with a doctor. "We don't want to see nursing care substituted for physician care," said Dr. Edward Hill, president-elect of the AMA. "This type of clinic might not lend itself very well for continuity."

But Mai Pham, a senior researcher at the nonpartisan Center for Studying Health System Change, said the clinics could provide a better alternative for patients who might otherwise go to an emergency room for care or skip it altogether. "It's clearly meeting a market need, but there's also concerns about why it is there is such a need," Pham said.

Howe said MinuteClinics limit their work to common illnesses and are quick to send patients to emergency rooms or back to their primary doctors if other symptoms turn up. The clinics also pass records on to patients' doctors and help those who do not have a physician find one. Strep tests are the most common procedure performed at the clinics. That's what Theisen, a nurse who lives in the Minneapolis suburb of Maple Grove, wanted for her daughter in a hurry. "If we would have gone to our doctor, it would take an hour longer," she said.

The trip to the MinuteClinic cost Theisen an insurance co-payment -- the same amount she would have paid to see their regular doctor. "I grocery-shopped while I was waiting," she said.


Source

***************************

For greatest efficiency, lowest cost and maximum choice, ALL hospitals and health insurance schemes should be privately owned and run -- with government-paid vouchers for the very poor and minimal regulation.

Comments? Email me here. If there are no recent posts here, the mirror site may be more up to date. My Home Page is here or here.

***************************

Tuesday, June 28, 2005

BUREAUCRATIC KNOW-ALLS HIT A ROCK

They leapt to judgment on the basis of statistics and now find that they haven't even got enough evidence to file charges. Are the Feds going to pay for the huge losses they caused? Not likely

The FBI's case against two prominent Redding physicians, suspected of performing hundreds of unnecessary heart procedures, appears to have stalled. Despite repeated rumors of impending criminal indictments against the doctors the past two years, no fraud charges have been filed by the U.S. attorney's office. The delay has frustrated lawyers whose own legal interests may be affected by the outcome of a federal case.

In late October 2003, the FBI dropped a bombshell on Northern California with its 80-page affidavit detailing the alleged operating room shenanigans of two of Redding's most revered doctors. Over the next 2 1/2 years, the allegations against cardiologist Chae Hyun Moon and cardiac surgeon Fidel Realyvasquez Jr. would divide the Shasta County community, garner national media attention, shutter a lucrative cardiac surgery program and result in more than $400 million in settlement payments for victims of the alleged wrongdoing.

A spokeswoman for the U.S. attorney's office in Sacramento did not respond to inquiries on the delay. But several observers suggested an investigating federal grand jury may be hampered by the complexity of the medical procedures in question and the range of opinion about what constitutes the accepted standard of care. "In today's world, you can find competing experts," said McGeorge School of Law professor Mike Vitiello. "It's difficult to make reasoned decisions about highly technical matters when expert opinions are in stark contrast to one another." Moon, for example, was known to forgo more conventional diagnostic tools, such as the treadmill stress test, to determine a patient's risk for heart attack. Instead, he often used the intravascular ultrasound, or IVUS, a costly and rarely used technology known to produce results only specially trained experts can decipher. Moon claimed the IVUS was superior to the less expensive approaches, but experts consulted early in the investigation said the surgeries Moon recommended based on his IVUS analyses were unnecessary.

According to the FBI affidavit, Realyvasquez and Moon performed excessive numbers of costly and invasive diagnostic procedures and heart surgeries compared with their counterparts in Northern California. Agents said Realyvasquez was ranked No. 1 on a Medicare list of 50 cardiologists paid in Northern California between July 2001 and July 2002. In that 12-month period he billed the federal government more than $3.5 million and was paid $767,600. For his part, Moon billed Medicare $3.9 million and was paid $1.6 million.

To convict the doctors of fraud, federal prosecutors would have to prove that Moon and Realyvasquez intended to deceive the government by knowingly performing unnecessary operations, then billing Medicaid or Medicare for their services. Proving medical malpractice is less complex and the stakes are lower, experts said. "The purpose of the criminal justice system is to take bad people who have done bad things and segregate them from society," said Vitiello. "If a doctor is careless, do we really want to hold over their head the risk of going to prison for that mistake?"

The civil cases against the doctors have moved more quickly. In January, Moon and three other Redding cardiologists settled with hundreds of patients for $24 million. Tenet Healthcare Corp., which owned Redding Medical Center, where the surgeries took place, paid $395 million to patients and $54 million to the federal government.

Realyvasquez and three other surgeons have refused to settle the civil cases, and a trial is scheduled to begin in September. "I have an absolute and firm belief that Doctor Realyvasquez only acted for the benefit of his patients," said Malcolm Segal, one of the surgeon's attorneys. Segal said he hopes the criminal matter is resolved before the civil trial starts in the fall. "It would be much easier to handle the civil litigation if the federal inquiry had concluded without any charges filed," he said.

The surgeon's ability to practice medicine remains tenuous. Although the Medical Board of California never filed a formal accusation against him, Realyvasquez has not practiced medicine since February 2003. "The allegations and the efforts refuting the statements made by others has consumed an enormous amount of his time," Segal said. "It has been extraordinarily expensive for him." Moon, who faces a formal board accusation, agreed to a temporary license suspension in June 2003, and it remains in effect pending the outcome of any criminal proceeding. His attorney did not return telephone calls.

Stephen Boreman, the deputy attorney general in charge of the medical board's case, said that while everyone involved would like to know how the U.S. attorney's office will proceed, he's confident the public is being well-served. "The public is protected because (the doctors) are not practicing medicine," he said. "I don't view this as anything negative for the people of California." [Since loss of highly skilled medical services to a community can only be detrimental, this is nothing more than prejudging the doctors as guilty]

Source




Bad medicine: "History is full of failed experiments in government control of the distribution of goods and services; some are still ongoing (Cuba). The results speak for themselves: wherever free trade and economic rights are stifled, shortages abound. We can even find examples of that here in the US: Nixon's attempts at price and wage controls as well as today's health care 'crisis' caused not by the private practice of medicine but by government's growing influence in this sector."

***************************

For greatest efficiency, lowest cost and maximum choice, ALL hospitals and health insurance schemes should be privately owned and run -- with government-paid vouchers for the very poor and minimal regulation.

Comments? Email me here. If there are no recent posts here, the mirror site may be more up to date. My Home Page is here or here.

***************************

Monday, June 27, 2005

CANADIANS GETTING FED UP WITH DANGEROUS DENIAL OF MEDICAL SERVICES

Breast cancer patients sue over radiotherapy wait times

Quebec Superior Court Justice John Bishop has authorized a class action suit on behalf of 10 000 Quebec breast cancer patients who contend they had to wait too long for radiotherapy. "This is the first time someone has taken action against waiting lists," says Montréal lawyer Michel Savonitto, who filed the suit in 2000 at the request of a Montréal woman. Bishop's precedent-setting ruling could open the door to similar lawsuits across Canada.

Anahit Cilinger had a partial mastectomy with lymph node removal in October 1999 and was put on a waiting list for radiotherapy. Twelve weeks later, she was still waiting. There was no place in Quebec where she could receive radiotherapy, and she couldn't get confirmation of plans to send her to the US. Angry and anxious, she returned to her native Turkey, where she paid US$12 000 for radiotherapy at an Istanbul hospital. "Nobody could tell her what the final delay would be," says Savonitto. "For her, it was unacceptable."

Cilinger spearheaded the class action suit. "I don't want other women to suffer the way I did while I was waiting for my treatment," she said. If the suit is successful, Savonitto estimates it could cost hospitals $25 million to $50 million. Savonitto filed more than a dozen medical articles to back his case. The evidence convinced Bishop that a medically acceptable delay between breast cancer surgery and radiotherapy ranges from 8 to 12 weeks. In his 41-page decision, delivered Mar. 9, he acknowledged a higher risk of breast cancer recurrence exists after longer delays.

Hospital administrators at the dozen Quebec hospitals named in the lawsuit may have to defend their decisions in court. The court must decide what constitutes an acceptable standard of care for women who need radiotherapy after breast cancer surgery. The real question, says Margaret Somerville, founding director of the McGill Centre for Medicine, Ethics and Law, is whether failing at that standard constitutes negligence. "These time periods seem very important," she admits, "but this is a zero-sum game. There's only so much money [in the health care system]. What do we do?"

Source

***************************

For greatest efficiency, lowest cost and maximum choice, ALL hospitals and health insurance schemes should be privately owned and run -- with government-paid vouchers for the very poor and minimal regulation.

Comments? Email me here. If there are no recent posts here, the mirror site may be more up to date. My Home Page is here or here.

***************************

Sunday, June 26, 2005

Hope snatched from dying child by government medical system

In Australia's notorious State of New South Wales, unsurprisingly

After being told two months ago nothing could be done to save her, a little girl received an extraordinary second chance at life, only to have it taken away. Kayla Hilderbrandt's health improved just enough to ensure she could survive surgery to replace her faulty heart valve. Her doctors and parents seized the window of opportunity, booking her in for urgent surgery at Sydney's Westmead Children's Hospital.

Since being admitted last week, her life-saving operation has been cancelled three times because the hospital had no intensive care beds available. She is angry, her parents are angry, but the hospital says there is nothing they can do about it. "I felt angry because they made me fast and not drink and my stomach gets all upset," Kayla said from her hospital bed yesterday. "The medicine was disgusting and made me feel like wanting to be sick."

It has been an emotional roller coaster for the 13-year-old from Mangrove Mountain on the NSW Central Coast, who has been too ill to go to school for most of this year. She is terrified about the surgery and has been even more anxious each of the three nights before her scheduled operations, which required fasting and special anti-bacterial bathing.

Kayla's mother Gina was especially distressed yesterday, saying the cancellation of her child's surgery was "absolutely disgusting". "They are using the ICU as an overflow from the emergency department, so there is no room for any of the surgical patients," she said. "All the kids who needed heart operations were cancelled the same day that Kayla was. "Kayla needs this surgery now while she is well enough to have it. Two months ago we were told there was no hope for her."

Mrs Hilderbrandt said her daughter suffered from high blood pressure, which had been managed with medication for four years. This year the medication stopped working, leaving Kayla's liver and kidneys congested because her heart was so weak. Doctors have told the family Kayla needs her mitral valve replaced - one of the heart's major valves.

Her operation has been rescheduled for Wednesday, with no guarantees it will definitely go ahead. "I just want a yes/no answer," Kayla's father Kit said. "I don't want her prepared for surgery only to have it cancelled again." Westmead Children's Hospital CEO Professor Kim Oates said the hospital would "move heaven and earth" to ensure Kayla's booking for surgery on Wednesday morning will go ahead. Professor Oates said Kayla's surgery was cancelled because the ICU was full because of the problems caused by the busy winter period. "It's not a financial problem, it's a staffing problem," he said. "We won't do heart surgery unless we have a fully-staffed ICU bed for the next 72 hours."

Kayla is just one of up to 30 per cent of surgical patients across the state whose operations are cancelled on the day because an intensive care bed is not available for them. Dr Patrick Cregan, chair of the NSW Health's Surgical Services Taskforce, established last year to manage surgery patients, said Westmead Hospital's cancellation rate was close to 30 per cent for patients needing an intensive care bed after their operation. "It is always terribly distressing for the patient to be cancelled on the day of their operation," he said. "The patients for which it happens more frequently is those needing intensive care beds."

Source







AMBULANCES UNDER ATTACK IN BRITAIN

The number of ambulances could be halved within the next six years as part of an overhaul of emergency care in the NHS. A government review of ambulance services to be published next week is expected to recommend a sharp reduction in the number of people taken to accident and emergency departments. Non-urgent call-outs, such as a cut finger or earache, are to be given to a growing army of emergency care practitioners (ECPs), who are trained to treat minor ailments outside hospital. Peter Bradley, the national ambulance adviser to the Department of Health and leader of the review, told a conference last week that he could envisage a significant decrease in ambulance use.

A cut in the number of ambulances is not suggested in the review, although it will outline the importance of a significant reallocation of resources to make the service more focused on "treatment than transport". It is known that Mr Bradley and George Alberti, the national director for emergency access, hope to increase the use of ECPs, who combine elements of nursing, medicine and the role of paramedics. ECPs travel alone in people carriers carrying the basic equipment for their work.

The national ambulance review will outline ways to reduce the number of patients taken to accident and emergency departments by a million a year. Mr Bradley, the chief executive of the London Ambulance Service Trust, said that he wanted to see the service becoming a "mobile unit of the NHS taking healthcare to patients". His vision, outlined at the NHS Confederation conference and reported in Health Service Journal, includes doctors dealing with 999 calls in call centres, with ECPs taking on extra services such as diagnostics and blood sampling. "We are going to see a big shift from not only providing clinical guidance in the field but also in the control centres - dealing with patients at source rather than elsewhere," he said. Mr Bradley said that in London ECPs could rise from 3 to 30 per cent of the NHS workforce by 2011. Less than half of all callers would be taken to A&E, compared with three-quarters now. "Maybe in 2011 we'll have only half as many (ambulances)," he said. "We'll have ECPs singly responding in people carriers. We'll be a lot less reliant on a big 3-tonne ambulance going out at o140,000 apiece."

Last night the Department of Health denied that any ambulances would be cut as part of the overhaul of emergency care. The BBC Radio 4 Today programme yesterday highlighted discrepancies in ambulance response times by different trusts. The programme claimed that many trusts do not start the clock until 1® or 2 minutes after the call is received, and in at least one case the delay may be as much as 3 or 4 minutes, distorting results

Source

***************************

For greatest efficiency, lowest cost and maximum choice, ALL hospitals and health insurance schemes should be privately owned and run -- with government-paid vouchers for the very poor and minimal regulation.

Comments? Email me here. If there are no recent posts here, the mirror site may be more up to date. My Home Page is here or here.

***************************